Customer Reviews: Read 5 more reviews...
 A fascinating book November 25, 2003
Kurt A. Johnson (Marseilles, IL USA)
16 out of 17 found this review helpful
This book is an in-depth study of the war fought between the United Kingdom and Argentina over the Falkland Islands from April to June 1982. The book begins with a highly informative history of the islands, focusing on the two countries' claims to the islands. The war is recounted in excellent depth, focusing heavily on the British side. The final chapter is on the aftermath of the war, which is severely limited, due to the fact that the book was published in 1983.Finally, there are three excellent appendices: A covers the British task force, giving everything from silhouettes of the ships and airplanes through list of the units involved complete with their commanders; B lists the honors given to Falklands veterans; and appendix C contains the Franks Report on the conflict. The maps contained in the book are excellent, as are the numerous black-and-white pictures. This book is quite fascinating, and highly informative on the war. I found myself completely unable to put this book down, but just had to read a little more, and a little more, and a little more... I wish that it contained more information on the Argentine side, which would give the book more all-around information. However, that said, it is a great book, giving the reader a good idea of what happened both on the battlefield, and in the halls of the politicians (a great deal of the British side was run for more political, rather than military reasons). This is a great book, and I highly recommend it to anyone interested in this fascinating war.
A freak event in history January 10, 2006
Thomas Koetzsch (Hong Kong)
12 out of 13 found this review helpful
That’s what Max Hastings and Simon Jenkins call the battle between Britain and Argentina over the Falkland Islands. Their rather thorough study on the 1982 conflict makes a fascinating read.The authors start off with covering the history of the Falklands, which is quite useful background. Simon Jenkins does a good job detailing the political developments right up to the invasion. It would appear that the conflict was as much a result of the fallacies of modern diplomacy as a perceived need by the Argentinean regime to deflect the population from the domestic situation. That’s at least the message I took home from reading the authors’ account of the Seventeen Years’ War and Galtieri’s Gamble. The actual war is recounted in quite some detail, but largely from the British point of view as Argentinean sources were not freely available at the time of publication (1983). The book also gives the impression that the British were in a bit of trouble quite a number of times during the conflict, but that as a result of a lack of co-ordination (or call it rivalries) between the different services of the Argentinean forces, they got away with their own shortcomings. The authors note that if the different services had better co-ordinated their efforts, the British task of regaining the Islands would have been much harder if not impossible. At the end of the narrative, there are three excellent appendices on the Falkland Islands Task Force, the Honours List and the ‘Frank Report’ examining the ‘why it hadn’t been prevented in the first place’ issue. This is an excellent book on the subject.
The definitive general history of the conflict January 7, 2001
9 out of 10 found this review helpful
An excellent overview of the Falklands Conflict - both politically and militarily. As well as dealing with the conflict itself, a brief overview of the Falklands' history, and the specific problems leading to the outbreak of the conflict, are given.If there is one improvement that could be made, more detail on the attacks themselves would certainly have been of interest to me - both in the maps and the text. However, this is a strategic, not a tactical history and, as such, is one of the best examples of modern military history I have read.
Excellent March 8, 2000
4 out of 4 found this review helpful
A first class history of modern warfare. Deals with both the military and political aspects in a comprehensive but compelling narrative. Thoroughly recommended.
Still the best account of the war July 30, 2007
Doctor Syn (Dymchurch-Under-The-Wall)
8 out of 9 found this review helpful
Max Hastings is a journalist who has an unerring knack of writing for publications that I would normally walk a thousand miles to avoid. Notwithstanding this, however, I have to say that he has done an absolutely sterling job with this book.
Although first published in the immediate aftermath of the war it has withstood the test of time well and, as a general history of the conflict, it will probably not be surpassed.
If you want to read the best written, most accessible account of the Falklands war then, without doubt, this is the book you should buy.
|
